Eye Makeup Removers
Eye doctors do not recommend using an oil or cream makeup remover such as baby oil or a creamy makeup remover because the residue can irritate the eye. If it doesn't irritate your eyes, that could be a good choice for you. But my eyes have gotten increasingly sensitive after I had Lasik so I prefer to use an eye makeup remover and then use Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser to remove the residue. Cetaphil is very gentle and will not irritate the eye like some other cleansers.
The following eye makeup removers are favorites:
Lancome BI-FACIL Eye Makeup Remover - this is my favorite and it removes waterproof as well as non-waterproof eye makeup
Sephora FACE Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover - gentle and non-irritating, water and silicon based, requires soaking the cotton pad and holding it on the eye for 30 seconds to work properly
Clinique Naturally Gentle Eye Makeup Remover - gentle and great for sensitive eyes but not as effective on waterproof makeup
Almay Makeup Remover Pads - the non-oily version doesn't seem to work as well as the oily version
The Body Shop (Chamomile) - gentle, dissolves makeup but contains alcohol so be sure to cleanse or at least rinse with water and apply eye moisturizer
NARS Eye Makeup Remover - gentle and soothing but works on waterproof makeup, too
Or, as many people said, Baby Oil - see Home Remedies













